How to move changes between repositories (git cherry-pick)
I'm currently refactoring a project which has a lot of similar copies with some slight (most often) differences between them. A difference can be from a simple value to a complete feature. Of course the best way would be to move everything to be modular and configurable, but unfortunately in real life this doesn't always happen instantly (you can always dream about it).
So to save myself from doing any copy-paste I started playing around with different ideas how to do it using git (at least I would be able to play around with a terminal). At first experimentation started using
rebase, but unfortunately after some bigger changes it began to mess the history. So then I started experimenting with a
cherry-pick command. This gives me quite a good control of what commits to pick up and keeps the history clean. It just adds a little bit more typing.
If you feel confident in git, then check a "summary" of commands to get the idea.
Otherwise the step by step tutorial is available below (I tried my best to make it, but it can be improved a lot, suggestions are welcome). It doesn't contain any images as I don't think they are needed. Tutorial can be easily typed in the terminal, the only difference will be file system changes depending on operating system you are using.
The set up for a tutorial is simple:
- The repoone directory contains README.md files with the line This line will be the same between both repositories.
- repoone directory is a git repository.
- The repotwo directory is a copy of repoone.
Now make a change in repoone:
echo -e "\n\nThis will be moved from one repository to another\n\n" >> README.md
And then commit the changes:
git add README.md git commit -m "Add line about moving"
Now add another change which is only for repoone:
echo "This is only for repoone" > repoone.config
And then commit the changes:
git add repoone.config git commit -m "Add repoone configuration"
This should start feeling similar. Add one more change and commit it:
echo "__*.config__ files contain the configuration values" >> README.md git add README.md git commit -m "Add explanation about .config files"
For the next part of tutorial move to the second repository by executing:
To start moving changes between the repositories first we need to add it as a remote and download objects and refs from it.
Important: Note that I'm using Windows for the code example so you should escape the
D:\\gitcherrybetweenrepos\\repoone will be different depending on your OS and/or file organization, replace as needed.
git remote add repoone D:\\gitcherrybetweenrepos\\repoone git fetch --progress --prune repoone
Now when running the following command (tip: add it as an alias to your
git log --graph --decorate --pretty=oneline --abbrev-commit --all
It will output the following results (commit ids might be different on your run, replace as needed):
* f761364 (repoone/master) Add explanation about .config files * 80a8db4 Add repoone configuration * 2ac430f Add line about moving * 5745330 (HEAD, master) Initial commit
So we want to add 2ac430f & f761364 commits to this repository. The
cherry-pick command can be used for that:
git cherry-pick 2ac430f git cherry-pick f761364
[Optional] Let's try it with a branch:
# go back to the first repository cd ../repoone # create a branch git checkout -b add-branch-example # add some changes and commits touch branch-example.md git add branch-example.md git commit -m "Initial commit" echo -e "\n\nThis line only for repoone\n\n" >> README.md git add README.md git commit -m "Add repoone specific commit" date >> branch-example.md git add branch-example.md git commit -m "Add current date value"
Leave repoone here and return to repotwo (also at the same time retrieve the data from repoone):
cd ../repotwo # check the branches of repoone git remote show repoone # imagine we got a lot of stuff going on in the remote repository # so just get back one branch and no tags git fetch --progress -n repoone refs/heads/add-branch-example:refs/remotes/repoone/add-branch-example # check the git log git log --graph --decorate --pretty=oneline --abbrev-commit --all * 13b1080 (repoone/add-branch-example) Add current date value * 94b5a67 Add repoone specific commit * 240ae14 Initial commit * f761364 (repoone/master) Add explanation about .config files * 80a8db4 Add repoone configuration * 2ac430f Add line about moving | * 78427ed (HEAD, master) Add explanation about .config files | * 54bd60b Add line about moving |/ * 5745330 Initial commit
Now get the changes what are needed from the branch and merge it back to the master:
git checkout -b add-branch-example git cherry-pick 240ae14 git cherry-pick 13b1080 git checkout master git merge --no-ff add-branch-example
And because we're done the branch and remote can be removed (cleanup time):
git branch -d add-branch-example git remote rm repoone
You probably won't use this trick in your everyday projects, but it can definitely come in handy in case you will get into similar situation like me (refactoring a lot of copies of similar project).
What tricks you're using for similar situations?